Compare / putter

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

Within £113.25 of each other right now. Cheapest is £229.95 at Replay Golf, checked daily across 1 UK retailers.

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Scotty Cameron

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

from £229.95

at Replay Golf · 1 retailer

Lowest £196 · around its usual price

Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

Scotty Cameron

Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

from £0

Lowest £213 · good time to buy

Discount vs RRP

n/a
n/a

Price vs usual

Around its usual price
Good time to buy

Where to buy

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Buy at Replay Golf →See price history & full details →

Where to buy

Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

    See price history & full details →

    The verdict

    On price, the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter is the cheaper of the two: £113.25 less at £229.95, versus £343.20 for the Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5. But measured against its own history the Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5 is the stronger deal right now: it's below its typical price, while the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter is around its typical price. The Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter is the more widely available, at 1 UK retailers versus 0.

    Is now a good time to buy?

    Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

    Around its usual price

    Low £195.95 Now £229.95 High £279.95

    Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

    Good time to buy

    Low £212.95 Now £449 High £1,199

    Price history

    How each has moved since we started tracking
    Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

    Lowest tracked price per day, any condition. Caddence tracks both daily.

    Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

    Lowest tracked
    £195.95

    Seen 1 April 2026

    Average
    £230

    Typical over 105 days

    Highest tracked
    £279.95

    Most expensive seen

    Price range
    £84

    Tracked high − low

    Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

    Lowest tracked
    £212.95

    Seen 31 March 2026

    Average
    £498

    Typical over 151 days

    Highest tracked
    £1,199

    Most expensive seen

    Price range
    £986

    Tracked high − low

    Waiting for a better price?

    Set a free alert and we’ll email you when either drops to your target.

    Set a price alert →

    More putter comparisons

    Frequently Asked

    Common questions about the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom Putter - 5

    Prices shown are the cheapest in-stock price per retailer tracked by Caddence, updated daily. Always confirm the final price on the retailer's site.