Compare / putter

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Within £49.05 of each other right now. Cheapest is £229.95 at Replay Golf, checked daily across 19 UK retailers.

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Scotty Cameron

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

from £229.95

at Replay Golf · 1 retailer

Lowest £196 · around its usual price

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Scotty Cameron

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

from £279

at Preowned Golf · 18 retailers

Lowest £279 · lowest price we’ve seen

Discount vs RRP

n/a
38% off

Price vs usual

Around its usual price
Lowest price we’ve seen

Where to buy

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Buy at Replay Golf →See price history & full details →

Where to buy

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Buy at Preowned Golf →See price history & full details →

The verdict

On price, the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter is the cheaper of the two: £49.05 less at £229.95, versus £279 for the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter. But measured against its own history the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter is the stronger deal right now: it's at the lowest price we’ve tracked, while the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter is around its typical price. The Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter is the more widely available, at 18 UK retailers versus 1.

Is now a good time to buy?

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Around its usual price

Low £195.95 Now £229.95 High £279.95

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Lowest price we’ve seen

Low £279 Now £279 High £499

Price history

How each has moved since we started tracking
Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Lowest tracked price per day, any condition. Caddence tracks both daily.

Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter

Lowest tracked
£195.95

Seen 1 April 2026

Average
£230

Typical over 106 days

Highest tracked
£279.95

Most expensive seen

Price range
£84

Tracked high − low

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Lowest tracked
£279

At it right now

Average
£413

Typical over 144 days

Highest tracked
£499

Most expensive seen

Price range
£220

Tracked high − low

Waiting for a better price?

Set a free alert and we’ll email you when either drops to your target.

Set a price alert →

More putter comparisons

Frequently Asked

Common questions about the Scotty Cameron American Classic III Flange Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Putter

Prices shown are the cheapest in-stock price per retailer tracked by Caddence, updated daily. Always confirm the final price on the retailer's site.