Which is cheaper, the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) or the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter?

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter is currently the cheaper option, £417.00 less (£382.95 used vs £799.95).

How many UK retailers stock the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) and Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter?

The Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) is currently in stock at 0 UK retailers (cheapest: n/a at £799.95), and the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter at 6 (cheapest: Replay Golf at £382.95). Caddence tracks both across UK golf retailers daily.

Is the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) a good price right now?

Yes: at £799.95 the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) is at the lowest price we've tracked. It has ranged £799.95 to £2,500 over 92 days.

Is the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter a good price right now?

The Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter is currently £382.95, 22% below its typical price. Its lowest tracked price was £424.95 on 18 August 2026.

Compare / putter

Live · checked today · 6 UK retailers tracked

Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter

Watch this matchup

Quick verdict

Checked daily across 6 UK retailers

Price and availability verdict

Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) was last tracked at £799.95 on 27 July 2026, while Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter is currently £382.95 used. Deal scores are Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter 91/100; against tracked history, Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) is at its lowest tracked price and Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter is at its lowest tracked price. Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter is currently available from 6 UK retailers; Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) is not currently stocked.

View MY Girl Putter (2017) details → View Phantom 5 OC Putter details →

Lowest price new → Phantom 5 OC Most retailers → Phantom 5 OC

Product Cheapest 7-day 90-day trend Vs usual Buy

Scotty Cameron

MY Girl Putter (2017)

£799.95 last tracked No change at its low

Scotty Cameron

Phantom 5 OC Putter

£479 used from £382.95 ↑ £0.48 22% below usual Buy £479 → at Discount Golf Store

Scotty Cameron

MY Girl Putter (2017)

£799.95 last tracked

at its low

Scotty Cameron

Phantom 5 OC Putter

£479

used from £382.95

↑ £0.48 7 days

22% below usual

Buy £479 →

at Discount Golf Store

Deal intelligence

Should you buy now, or wait?

Both are at their lowest tracked prices today.

Scotty Cameron · MY Girl Putter (2017)

Not enough data yet

Today £799.95 · typical £1,299 · lowest £799.95

On sale 1 time in the last 3 months

Scotty Cameron · Phantom 5 OC Putter

Excellent deal today

Today £424.95 · typical £449 · lowest £424.95

Used from £382.95 10% less than new

Head to head

Category leaders, from the data on this page

Cheapest new Phantom 5 OC £424.95 vs £799.95
Most retailers in stock Phantom 5 OC 6 vs 0

Price trajectory

How each has moved since we started tracking

Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter

Lowest tracked price per day, any condition. Caddence tracks both daily. Shaded spans are days we couldn’t collect prices — the lines break rather than guessing.

Scotty Cameron · MY Girl Putter (2017)

↓ £499.05

since 9 April 2026

Lowest £799.95 on 16 July 2026

Scotty Cameron · Phantom 5 OC Putter

↓ £74.05

since 23 February 2026

Lowest £424.95 on 18 August 2026

New vs used

From used listings we track

Scotty Cameron · Phantom 5 OC Putter

NEW £424.95

USED FROM £382.95

Used prices average 90% of new · 1 used listing tracked

Waiting for a better price?

Set a free alert and we’ll email you when either drops to your target.

Set a price alert →

Related putter comparisons

More head-to-head price checks

Frequently Asked

Common questions about the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Putter (2017) vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 OC Putter

Prices shown are the cheapest in-stock price per retailer tracked by Caddence, updated daily. Always confirm the final price on the retailer's site.